Payday Loans

Payday Alternative Loans (PALs) From a Credit Union: PAL I vs. PAL II

A payday alternative loan is a small installment loan that a federal credit union can make under NCUA rules. Here is how PAL I and PAL II differ, who qualifies, how the 28% APR cap works, and what a PAL does not guarantee.

On this page

A payday alternative loan, or PAL, is a small installment loan that a federal credit union can make under rules written by the National Credit Union Administration (NCUA). This guide covers what the rules say about a PAL I and a PAL II, how the 28% APR cap works, who can borrow, and what a PAL does not guarantee. Both versions are defined in 12 CFR 701.21(c)(7)(iii) and (iv), and the rule’s figures below come from that text, and the current rate ceiling comes from the NCUA.

A PAL is a credit union product, so you need to belong to a credit union that offers one. That is the main practical hurdle, and it is why the section on finding one comes before the fine print. For the full list of ways to avoid a payday loan, see our guide to payday loan alternatives.

PAL I vs. PAL II at a glance

RulePAL IPAL II
Loan amount$200 to $1,000Up to $2,000
Term1 to 6 months1 to 12 months
Minimum membershipAt least 1 monthNo minimum period set by the rule
Maximum interest rateNCUA ceiling plus 10 points (28%)NCUA ceiling plus 10 points (28%)
Application feeReasonable, never more than $20Reasonable, never more than $20
Open at one timeOne PAL (I or II)One PAL (I or II)
In any rolling six monthsNo more than three PALs (I and II)No more than three PALs (I and II)
RolloversProhibitedProhibited
RepaymentFully amortizedFully amortized
Overdraft or NSF feesNot addressed in the PAL I ruleNot allowed on your account in connection with it

PAL I and PAL II compared to a typical payday loan

FeaturePAL IPAL IITypical state-law payday loan
Who lendsFederal credit unionFederal credit unionLicensed payday lender, where state law permits
CostAPR capped at 28% plus a fee of up to $20APR capped at 28% plus a fee of up to $20$10 to $30 per $100 borrowed, depending on state law; $15 per $100 is common
Equivalent APR28% maximum28% maximumAlmost 400% for a two-week loan at $15 per $100
RepaymentInstallments over 1 to 6 monthsInstallments over 1 to 12 monthsLump sum due on your next payday, typically in two weeks, per MyCreditUnion.gov
RolloversProhibitedProhibitedAllowed in some states, where you pay the fee again to extend the due date
Membership neededYes, at least 1 monthYes, no minimum period in the ruleNo

The cost and rollover rows come from the CFPB’s explanation of payday loan costs and fees, and the repayment row from MyCreditUnion.gov. Payday lending rules differ by state, and in some states payday lending is not permitted, so check the rules where you live. Our payday loan laws by state guide links to each state’s statute.

How the 28% APR cap works

The NCUA does not set 28% directly. The rule lets a federal credit union charge “1000 basis points above the maximum interest rate established by the Board” under paragraph (c)(7)(ii), and 1,000 basis points is 10 percentage points. The Board’s general ceiling for federal credit union loans is 18% as of November 2026, which the NCUA extended through September 10, 2027 (Letter to Federal Credit Unions 26-FCU-02). So 18% plus 10 points is a 28% cap on a PAL.

Two details matter. The cap is a ceiling, and a credit union can charge less. And because it is tied to the Board’s ceiling, a change in that ceiling changes the PAL cap, so confirm the current figure with the credit union.

The fee is separate. The rule allows a “reasonable application fee” that reflects the actual cost of processing the application, and in no case more than $20.

What the cap costs in dollars

The arithmetic below assumes the 28% maximum with equal monthly payments. The last column adds the largest application fee the rule allows ($20). Your own loan could cost less.

LoanMonthly paymentTotal interestInterest plus $20 fee
$500 over 3 months (PAL I or II)$174.50$23.51$43.51
$1,000 over 6 months (PAL I or II)$180.54$83.24$103.24
$1,500 over 12 months (PAL II only)$144.76$237.11$257.11

For comparison, a two-week payday loan at the CFPB’s $15-per-$100 example costs $75 in fees on $500 and has to be repaid in a lump sum. Even with the maximum $20 fee ($43.51 on the $500 loan), the PAL costs less, over a longer repayment schedule. Our installment vs. payday loans guide runs this comparison in full.

Borrowing limits and protections written into the rule

The same limits apply to both versions:

  • One at a time. A federal credit union may not make you more than one PAL (I or II) at a time.
  • Three in six months. It may not make you more than three PALs, counting PAL I and PAL II together, in any rolling six-month period.
  • No rollovers. The credit union cannot roll over a PAL. The rule does allow extending the term within the maximum term if that adds no fees and no additional credit.
  • Full amortization. Each payment reduces the principal, so the loan is paid off by the last scheduled payment rather than ending in a balloon.
  • Closed-end credit. A PAL is an installment loan with a set term, not a revolving line.

Credit unions also have limits of their own. The rule requires each credit union that offers PALs to cap its total PALs at 20% of its net worth and to set underwriting guidelines. Those limits are one reason a given credit union may offer only some PAL features or decline to offer PALs at all.

The rule also lists features a credit union may choose to add, such as a savings component, financial education, and reporting your payments to credit bureaus. These are suggestions in the rule, not requirements, so ask whether a credit union does them.

Who can get a PAL

You must be a member of a federal credit union that offers PALs. The rule’s membership requirement differs by version:

  • PAL I: you must have been a member for at least one month before you receive the loan.
  • PAL II: the rule sets no minimum membership period. A credit union can still have its own policies, so ask how soon after joining you can apply.

Who can join a credit union depends on its charter and field of membership, such as where you live, work, or worship, or an association you belong to. The credit union also decides whether to approve you. The rule requires credit unions that offer PALs to have underwriting guidelines and gives verifying employment with at least two recent pay stubs as an example, so expect to show proof of income.

How to find a credit union that offers PALs

  1. Search the NCUA’s Credit Union Locator by address, ZIP code, or name to see credit unions near you. The PAL rule covers federal credit unions, whose names usually include “Federal Credit Union”; MyCreditUnion.gov notes that many state-chartered credit unions offer similar products.
  2. Check eligibility to join. Each credit union’s website lists who can become a member.
  3. Ask directly about PALs. Do not assume a credit union offers them. Ask whether they offer a PAL I, a PAL II, or both, the rate, the application fee, and how quickly you can apply after joining.
  4. Be cautious about the label. The NCUA’s consumer site, MyCreditUnion.gov, warns that some lenders that are not credit unions use “payday alternative loan” wording, and their terms may not be good for you. A real PAL comes from a federal credit union.

If you are not yet a member of any credit union, joining before you need a loan avoids the PAL I waiting period.

What a PAL does not guarantee

  • Approval. A credit union underwrites each application. A PAL does not guarantee approval.
  • An amount. The rule sets a range. The credit union decides how much, if anything, it will lend you.
  • A low rate. 28% is a maximum, and each credit union sets its own rate up to it. Other federal credit union loans are capped at 18% (as of November 2026), so a standard credit union loan may cost less than a PAL if you qualify for one. MyCreditUnion.gov notes this too.
  • That your credit union offers one. PALs are optional for credit unions, so yours may not offer one.
  • Same terms everywhere. Fees, term lengths, and speed vary by credit union within the rule’s limits.
  • That it fits your budget. A fully amortized PAL still has to be repaid on schedule, and the monthly payment can be larger than a one-time fee suggests. If you cannot afford it, our guide on what to do if you can’t make this month’s payment covers the order to try things in.

If a PAL is not available to you

If you do not belong to a credit union or yours does not offer a PAL, you have other options. Our guide to payday loan alternatives covers bank small-dollar loans, employer help, community assistance, and the costs of each. If you are already stuck in a payday loan, see escaping the payday loan cycle.

If you have worked through those and a short-term loan is still the right tool, you can submit a loan request through our form. Be clear about what that is: we’re paid by lending networks for loan requests submitted through our form, we are not a lender, and submitting does not guarantee an offer. Lenders reached through our form are not credit unions making PALs, so the 28% cap above does not apply to them, and APRs for short-term loans can exceed 400%.

Sources

Frequently Asked Questions

What is a payday alternative loan?

A payday alternative loan (PAL) is a small, closed-end installment loan that a federal credit union can make under the NCUA's rule at 12 CFR 701.21(c)(7). A PAL I is $200 to $1,000 over one to six months. A PAL II is up to $2,000 over one to twelve months. Both must be fully amortized, cannot be rolled over, and any application fee is capped at $20.

What is the difference between a PAL I and a PAL II?

Four differences. A PAL I is $200 to $1,000 and a PAL II is up to $2,000. A PAL I runs one to six months and a PAL II one to twelve. A PAL I requires at least one month of credit union membership, while the rule sets no minimum membership period for a PAL II. A credit union also may not charge overdraft or non-sufficient funds fees on the borrower's account in connection with a PAL II. The interest cap, application fee cap, and borrowing limits are the same.

How much can you borrow with a PAL?

Under the NCUA rule at 12 CFR 701.21(c)(7)(iii), a PAL I is $200 to $1,000 and a PAL II is up to $2,000. Those are ceilings and floors set by the rule, not amounts you are owed. A credit union decides whether it offers PALs, sets its own underwriting, and may lend less. You can have one PAL at a time and no more than three in any rolling six-month period.

What is the maximum APR on a payday alternative loan?

A federal credit union may charge 1,000 basis points (10 percentage points) above the interest rate ceiling the NCUA Board sets. As of November 2026, the ceiling is 18%, extended through September 10, 2027, so the PAL cap is 28%. If the ceiling changes, the PAL cap moves with it. The rate a credit union actually charges can be lower.

Do I have to be a member to get a PAL?

Yes, you borrow from a credit union you belong to. For a PAL I the rule requires at least one month of membership before you receive the loan. For a PAL II the rule sets no minimum membership period, but each credit union decides who may join and may have its own policies. Join first, then ask what the credit union offers.

How many payday alternative loans can I have?

One at a time, and no more than three in any rolling six-month period. The limit counts PAL I and PAL II loans together. The rule also bars rollovers, though a credit union may extend a PAL's term within the maximum term if that adds no fees and no new credit.

Will I be approved for a payday alternative loan?

Not necessarily. A PAL does not guarantee approval, an amount, or a rate. The NCUA's rule requires each credit union to set underwriting guidelines, with at least two recent pay stubs given as an example of employment verification, and the credit union decides whether to offer PALs at all. The rule's limits are ceilings, not promises.

How do I find a credit union that offers PALs?

Use the NCUA's Credit Union Locator to find credit unions near you, then call or check the credit union's loan page and ask whether it offers PAL I or PAL II loans and who is eligible to join. Do not assume a credit union offers PALs, so ask.

Need a loan?

Answer a few questions and your request goes to the lending networks we work with. If a lender wants to make you an offer, you review its exact terms before you accept anything. Or compare the lenders we review first.