Mariner Finance vs Upstart

★ Editor's Pick
Feature
Mariner Finance
Mariner Finance, LLC
Upstart
Upstart Network, Inc.
Rating 3.6 4.5
Loan Type personal personal
APR Range 15.99% – 35.99%6.1% – 35.99%
Loan Amount $1,000 – $25,000 $1,000 – $75,000
Term Length 12 – 72 months36 – 60 months
Pros
  • APR capped at 35.99%, a fraction of payday and high-cost online installment loans
  • Checking offers is a soft inquiry with no effect on your credit score
  • Branch network, so you can close the loan in person with a loan officer
  • Return the money within 15 days and pay no fees if you change your mind
  • Starting APR of 6.1%
  • Considers education and job history, not just credit score
  • Fast funding after approval in many states
  • Borrowers with thin credit files often qualify
Cons
  • Starting APR of 15.99% is high for borrowers with good credit
  • Does not publish its fees, and the amount financed can include charges other than interest
  • Eleven attorneys general are plaintiffs in a lawsuit filed in 2022 over add-on insurance, mailed "live checks," and loan flipping
  • Available in only 29 states
  • Origination fee comes out of your proceeds, and Upstart doesn't publish its range
  • Not available to residents of West Virginia or Iowa
  • High maximum APR for higher-risk borrowers
Requirements
  • Live in one of the 29 states where Mariner is licensed
  • Credit history, income, and existing debt payments are reviewed
  • Larger loans or lower rates may require a vehicle no more than 10 years old, titled in your name and insured
  • Georgia residents must borrow more than $3,000
  • At least 18 (19 in some states)
  • US citizen or permanent resident
  • Valid bank account
  • Verifiable income or job offer starting within 6 months
Review Review

The short version

Mariner Finance is a branch-based installment lender licensed in 29 states; Upstart is an online lending marketplace whose loans are originated by banks — primarily Cross River Bank and FinWise Bank — using an underwriting model that also weighs education and employment history. Mariner lends $1,000 to $25,000 over 12 to 72 months at APRs of 15.99% to 35.99% as of September 2026, and it doesn’t publish an origination fee, a late fee, or a fee schedule on its personal loan page. Upstart lends $1,000 to $75,000 over 36- or 60-month terms at APRs of 6.10% to 35.99%, and it doesn’t publish a range for its origination fee — the only figure it states publicly is the 8.31% fee from its own representative example.

Upstart’s underwriting is aimed at borrowers a credit-score-only lender would pass over: it weighs education and employment history alongside credit and will count a job offer starting within six months in place of current income. Mariner’s draw is its branch network and a vehicle-collateral option for applicants who don’t qualify for its lower rates or larger amounts, plus a 15-day return policy. Mariner is also the subject of a lawsuit filed in 2022 by the attorneys general of Pennsylvania, New Jersey, Oregon, Washington, and the District of Columbia and joined in 2024 by six more states, which alleges it added insurance and other add-on products to loans without consent, mailed unsolicited “live checks,” and pushed borrowers to refinance; in January 2024 a court denied Mariner’s motion to dismiss, and the allegations have not been proven.

Rates and fees

Mariner’s published range is 15.99% to 35.99% APR, and it doesn’t publish an origination fee, a late fee, or a fee schedule on its personal loan page — it notes that the amount financed may not be what you receive if charges other than interest are included. Upstart’s published range is 6.10% to 35.99% APR; its origination fee comes out of your proceeds before the money is sent, but Upstart doesn’t publish the range that fee can span, so the 8.31% figure in its own representative example is the only number it states publicly.

Take a $10,000 loan over 36 months at the midpoint of each lender’s published APR range, to compare the two on equal footing.

Mariner Finance, 25.99% APR (midpoint of 15.99%-35.99%). Mariner doesn’t publish an origination fee or a fee schedule, so we’re assuming no fee here. An APR already includes the origination fee by definition, so on a loan with no fee at all, we simply amortize the full $10,000 you receive at 25.99% APR over 36 months. That works out to a payment of about $402.85 a month, $14,502.60 total paid, and a total cost of about $4,502.60 in interest. If your loan carries charges other than interest, your cash in hand would be lower and your true cost higher than this figure shows. These are our own amortization figures, not a lender quote.

Upstart, 21.05% APR (midpoint of 6.10%-35.99%), using the 8.31% fee from its own published representative example. Upstart doesn’t publish a range for this fee — 8.31% is the only figure it states publicly, not a midpoint. The fee is $831.00, so you’d receive about $9,169.00 in cash. An APR already includes the origination fee by definition, so we amortize the cash you actually receive at the APR rather than counting the fee a second time: a payment of about $345.68 a month, total payments of about $12,444.48, and a total cost of roughly $3,275.48 over the $9,169.00 you actually received. These are our own amortization figures, not a lender quote.

Upstart’s own published example uses different terms: a $10,000 loan over 60 months at a 19.12% interest rate with the same 8.31% fee, for a 23.48% APR, works out to $261 a month and about $15,660 total paid. Mariner’s own published example is a $5,000 loan at 30.99% APR (27.98% interest) over 48 months: payments of $182.91 a month and a finance charge of $3,779.68, for $8,779.68 repaid in total.

Who qualifies

Mariner doesn’t publish a minimum credit score. It bases rates and fees on your credit history, income, debt payments, whether you offer collateral, and, for Mariner-originated loans, your state; applicants who don’t qualify for its lower rates or larger amounts may need to pledge a first lien on a vehicle no more than 10 years old, titled in their name and insured. Checking offers is a soft inquiry; accepting one triggers a hard inquiry.

Upstart doesn’t publish a minimum credit score either; its model also weighs education, employment history, and income. You need to be at least 18 (19 in Alabama, Nebraska, and Puerto Rico), a US citizen or permanent resident, and have a valid bank account; a confirmed job offer starting within six months can stand in for current income. Checking your rate is a soft inquiry, and a hard inquiry follows only if you accept an offer.

Speed and funding

Mariner doesn’t publish a funding time on its personal loan page. You can apply online or at a branch; some loans close by phone or online with electronic documents, but not every loan type qualifies for remote closing, so a branch visit may be required. Mariner also offers a 15-day return policy: return the money within 15 days and it says you pay no fees. Upstart says most approved borrowers who accept their offer receive funds within one business day, with the exception of loans used for education or tuition expenses, which federal Truth in Lending rules hold for three business days regardless of lender.

Where each one wins

  • Mariner Finance — branches, so you can close the loan in person with a loan officer.
  • Mariner Finance — a 15-day return policy: return the money within 15 days and pay no fees.
  • Upstart — a lower APR floor (6.10% versus Mariner’s 15.99%) as of September 2026.
  • Upstart — an underwriting model that counts education, employment history, and a job offer starting within six months, for borrowers with a thin credit file.
  • Upstart — a loan ceiling of $75,000, three times Mariner’s $25,000.

Bottom line

If your credit file is thin or you have a job offer lined up but no income history yet, Upstart’s underwriting model and lower APR floor make it worth checking first. If you want to close in person, don’t qualify for an online lender’s range, or may need to offer a vehicle as collateral, Mariner’s branch network is the one built for that, though its 15.99% floor and undisclosed fees mean a borrower with strong credit would likely pay more there. Personal loans with bad credit covers more options if you’re declined by either. Read the full Mariner Finance review and Upstart review, then start a loan request to see what you might actually qualify for.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is it easier to get approved for Mariner Finance or Upstart?

Neither publishes a minimum credit score. Mariner says it bases rates and fees on your credit history, income, debt payments, whether you offer collateral, and, for Mariner-originated loans, your state, without a published cutoff. Upstart weighs education, employment history, and even a job offer starting within six months — a path Mariner doesn't describe on the pages we checked. Checking your rate with either lender is a soft inquiry that leaves your score untouched.

Which is cheaper, Mariner Finance or Upstart?

On published floors, Upstart's APR starts far lower (6.10% versus Mariner's 15.99%) as of September 2026. Upstart doesn't publish a fee range — only the 8.31% fee from its own representative example — while Mariner doesn't publish a fee at all. Using those figures at the midpoint of each lender's APR range on a $10,000, 36-month loan, Upstart comes out cheaper than the assumed no-fee Mariner figure below in both monthly payment and total cost.

What credit score do you need for Mariner Finance vs. Upstart?

Neither lender states a minimum. Mariner weighs your credit history, income, debt payments, and whether you offer collateral, without a published number. Upstart doesn't publish a minimum credit score, and its model also factors in education, employment history, and income.

Which lender funds faster, Mariner Finance or Upstart?

Mariner doesn't publish a funding time on its personal loan page; some loans can close by phone or online with electronic documents, but not every loan type qualifies for remote closing, so a branch visit may be required. Upstart says most approved borrowers who accept their offer receive funds within one business day, except loans for education or tuition expenses, which federal Truth in Lending rules hold for three business days.

How do Mariner Finance's and Upstart's loan sizes and terms compare?

Mariner lends $1,000 to $25,000 over 12 to 72 months, with Georgia residents required to borrow more than $3,000. Upstart lends $1,000 to $75,000, but only over 36- or 60-month terms, with higher minimums in Georgia ($3,100), Hawaii ($1,500), and Massachusetts ($7,000). Upstart's ceiling is three times Mariner's, while Mariner offers far more term lengths to choose from.

Compare Different Products Apply Now We're paid by lending networks for loan requests submitted through our form.

By EconoCents Editorial Team · Figures from each lender's published rates and terms; ratings per how we rate lenders. ·

Sources

Figures we cite from these primary sources were last checked on and are re-checked every week.